Well I have had my iPhone 4 for over 2 weeks now, so I think its about time I made some comments on the thing.
Look and Feel
The first thing you think on picking up the phone is “wow, this is well built”. It really is too, nicely machined, and it feels right in the hand. The new squarer feel to the device means it sits very nicely with your hands right over the antenna (more on that later!).
Apparently the back of the phone is glass too, so you need to be careful not to bump into things as you walk along. Apple claim that the screen is twenty times stronger than on the old iPhone, but that not the kinda thing I am going to test with my own device.
A friend of mine has told me that there are scratches on his phone already. He is relatively careful with his phone and its in a case, but there is no screen protector. My own phone remains unscathed. I have put it in my Nexus Ones neoprene sleeve though. I do tend to be a bit overprotective with my phone. My previous iPhone 3G stayed in a pocket without keys or change in, but had a habit of picking up bits of tissue in the dock and headphone connectors.
Top tip, unless you like scraping bits of tissue out of your iPhones most delicate regions with a paperclip stick it in some sort of case!
My wifes 3GS has always felt a bit flimsy to me, none of the newer models have felt quite as good as the original metal backed iPhone. the 4 however feels better than this. Its helped by the quality of the volume buttons, the slider that puts the phone into silent mode and the ‘home’ button. Which feels far more clicky that previous efforts.
Software
the iOS 4 software is a reasonable evolution of the device. There is some multitasking finally built in – accessed by double clicking the home button. Frankly its a bit rubbish. Yes you can now set last.fm playing in the background while you go to Safari to check out a page. Who really did this though? I am willing to bet that most people just used the iPod app anyway, which always ran in the background.
The fact that navigation apps run better is all very well, but again I dont need a nav app every day. What I would like to happen is for my Twitter app to run properly in the background, updating itself so when I come back to it I DONT NEED TO REFRESH IT. As you can probably guess this doesnt happen.
I am probably being slightly unfair as I am sure that this kind of behaviour will be supported in an app update rather than an operating system one.
Frankly its just fast app switching in most cases rather than true multitasking
The most visually obvious changes are wall paper and folders. The fact you can group all your ‘Travel’ apps altogether in one folder is lovely, not revolutionary but very nice indeed. And I can set my own backgrounds and nit just the lock screen? Fine – they arent animated as they were in Android but at the same time they dont suck the battery dry in about 2 hours either.
Speed
Yes the phone is faster to launch apps, play games, surf the web and carry out tasks like that. One area is definitely faster is in obtaining a GPS lock, its practically instantaneous. Nice job Apple.
I have yet to see it ‘lagging’ doing anything, which was a real problem on my 1ghz N1. Sometimes the android phone would take up to a minute to respond to a key press in the Messaging application. Tiresome? Yup.
Suffice it to say the iPhone is plenty fast enough. I don’t think its a dramatic speed up compared to the 3GS (massive over the 3G) but its good enough for me.
Lock Screen & Notifications
I may have hinted about this before. The iPhone lock screen and notifications suck. To be completely fair, the standard Android lock screen REALLY sucks. Slide left to unlock (which you can only activate in the first place by clicking the top button, why not the click wheel Google HUH?, huh?) or slide to the right to silence. Its pants.
You can make it full of win though by installing FlyScreen ,http://www.myflyscreen.com/ which shows you all sorts of things that you might want to see without having to DO anything to your phone, like…see what calls you have missed, or emails, or texts.
The iPhone unlocks the same way as it always has, slide to the right. It also gives you useful info like 2 missed calls and 2 texts waiting. Doesn’t give you nearly enough info though. A bit pants. You need to unlock and then hunt around all your apps looking for the little red number badges against them to really figure it out.
That’s the ‘notification’ side of this, all notifications on the iPhone take the form of a blue rectangle on the screen with VERY limited info on it.
On Android you get the bar at the top that populates with all the information that you need to know, number of missed called, texts, tweets emails etc. If you want more detail you slide it down and get the detail. Awesome. Simple and very effective.
In fact I think its the only thing I really liked about Android.
Unified Inbox
A small bit of Android bashing again…sorry. Why do I need 2 email apps? 1 for gmail and one for everything else! 1 is fine thank you.
iPhone now does a unified inbox, that it all your email forms one steady stream into one place. Nice. You can still view them separately but really, why would you?
You can also have multiple exchange accounts on the device, I use google to sync all my calendars, mail and contacts which uses exchange to ‘push’ it all to my phone. My work account is Exchange based and does the same. They. Just. Work. Together. END OF
Nice
Battery Life
Is great. With normal use I can now go 2 days between charges. By normal use I mean:
- Frequent checking of Twtter
- WiFi on all the time
- 3G on all the time
- Push email/contacts/calendar from 2 accounts
- There are currently 22 active ‘multitasked’ apps running
Now that’s pretty good I think. N1 did 12 at a push, I now feel comfortable leaving the house without a charger.
Reception
Yeah, this is the kicker I think. There has been an awful lot of press about the iPhone 4’s flawed antenna. Even non-geeks know by know that if you hold your phone a certain way its going to drop calls.
Yes I can make it do it. If I carry out the ‘grip of death’ and cover the antenna I can make the reception gradually drop bars and switch to ‘searching’. I could do this on the N1 as well by cupping the bottom of the phone. Obviously I had never bothered to even try it until the iPhone issues came up.
In real world use however. I haven’t had an issue with it, calls seem clearer, none have dropped on me so far…
Its fine, I wouldn’t take my phone back, most people use a case (I don’t) its a bit of a non issue really
However
It is fairly crap by Apple to not really acknowledge that there IS a problem and telling users that there is a software fix (we are going to display fewer bars) is a rubbish response. Give away a free case and acknowledge the problem Apple. Sheesh
Facetime
its a pointless gimmick. Get used to it
Summing Up
I hope this has been a fairly balanced review, if anything it may come over as slightly negative. Why am I using the iPhone then?
Deep Breath
Basically it just works, it doesn’t crash randomly, it will let me answer frakking calls, text messages get sent without floating around in the ether for up to 2 days. its consistent app setting are all controlled in ‘Settings’ rather than in multiple menus buried within the app themselves, the app store contains genuinely useful, well built apps
Its good. Get one!